Officials arrested 22-year-old Philip Allen Jr., Wednesday morning in north Toledo. U.S. Marshals and Toledo Police found Allen hiding in the attic of a home on Ontario Street.
Police allege Allen and three other men broke into James Safadi's home in May.
During the break-in, Safadi was shot and killed in the 8900-block of S. River Road.
Lucas County Grand Jury indicted the three other men on murder and aggravated robbery charges.
18-year-old James Y. Allen, 20-year-old Adam Jovan Anderson, and 32-year-old Ronald Rooker are currently behind bars awaiting trial.